top of page
Search

Who Pays Legal Fees in a Trust Dispute?

2 hours ago
6 min read
Paying fees for a trust dispute

Who pays legal fees in a trust dispute? It’s one of the first questions people ask when a trust dispute turns into a lawsuit.


If you are a beneficiary considering a trust challenge, a trustee who has been sued, or a family member involved in trust litigation, the potential cost of attorney’s fees can be a major concern.


The short answer is: it depends.


In many lawsuits, each side is generally responsible for paying its own attorney’s fees. But trust and probate disputes can involve important exceptions. Depending on the circumstances, legal fees may sometimes be paid from the trust itself, or one party may be ordered to pay some or all of the other party’s legal fees.


Several factors can affect the outcome, including the role of the person involved, the nature of the dispute, the conduct of the parties, the language of the trust, and the law of the state where the dispute is being handled.


The General Rule: Each Side Pays Its Own Attorney’s Fees


Generally speaking, in the United States, each party is responsible for their own attorney’s fees, regardless of who ultimately wins the case.


That means that simply winning a lawsuit does not necessarily mean that the other side will automatically be required to reimburse you for your attorney’s fees.


Trust litigation, however, can involve additional rules and exceptions.


That is why the answer to the question, "Who pays legal fees in a trust dispute?" isn't always as straightforward as it might seem.


When Can a Trustee's Legal Fees Be Paid by the Trust?


One situation that can be particularly important involves a trustee who is defending actions taken in their capacity as trustee.


A trustee has responsibilities to administer the trust and manage trust property according to the governing documents and applicable law. If a beneficiary sues the trustee over actions the trustee took as part of that role, the trustee may, in some circumstances, be able to have legal expenses paid from trust assets.


For example, imagine that Carla is the trustee of her mother's trust.


One of the beneficiaries accuses Carla of improperly managing trust investments and files a lawsuit against her.


Depending on the circumstances, Carla's attorney's fees for defending the lawsuit may be payable from the trust while the case is pending, particularly if she is acting within her role as trustee and in good faith.


But there is an important qualification.


A trustee's access to trust funds for legal expenses does not necessarily mean the trustee will ultimately be entitled to keep that benefit.


If a court later determines that the trustee breached her fiduciary duties, seriously mismanaged the trust, or acted in bad faith, the court may determine that the trustee should reimburse the trust for fees that were paid on her behalf. Further reimbursement may also be denied.


In other words, the fact that a trustee is initially able to use trust assets to fund a defense does not necessarily resolve the question of who ultimately bears that expense.


Can a Beneficiary's Attorney's Fees Be Paid From the Trust?


Trust litigation can also raise the opposite question:


Can a beneficiary who brings a successful lawsuit have their attorney's fees paid from the trust?


In some circumstances, the answer may be yes.


One concept that can arise in these cases deals with the idea of a common fund. The basic idea is that a beneficiary may, under appropriate circumstances, seek reimbursement from the trust when their legal action creates a benefit for the trust or for the beneficiaries as a whole.


Consider another example.


Ben is a beneficiary of a trust. He discovers that the trustee has allegedly been taking excessive fees for years, reducing the amount of money available to all of the beneficiaries.

Ben brings a legal claim challenging the trustee's conduct. The claim is successful and results in the trust recovering money that otherwise would have been lost.


Because the lawsuit benefited the trust as a whole rather than merely benefiting Ben personally, a court may determine that some or all of his legal expenses should be paid from the trust.


That doesn't mean a beneficiary automatically gets their attorney's fees paid whenever they win a trust dispute.


The circumstances of the case matter, and whether fees can be recovered depends on the applicable law and the court's determination.


What Happens If a Trust Claim Is Frivolous or Made in Bad Faith?


There is another side to the equation.


A person who brings a trust-related lawsuit may sometimes face responsibility for the other side's attorney's fees if the claim is found to be frivolous, brought in bad faith, or otherwise unjustified under the applicable law.


For example, imagine that Diane receives less from a trust than her sibling.


Diane believes the distribution is unfair and files a lawsuit claiming that her sibling exercised undue influence over the person who created the trust.


But suppose there is little or no evidence supporting the allegation, and the court determines that the claim was legally unjustified or was brought for an improper purpose.

Depending on the applicable law and the circumstances, Diane could potentially be ordered to pay more than her own legal expenses. She could also be ordered to pay some of the trustee's or another party's attorney's fees.


This is one reason it's important to understand the potential financial consequences before filing a trust lawsuit.


A disagreement with the way a trust distributes property isn't necessarily enough to establish a valid legal claim.


The Trust Document Itself May Matter


Another factor that can affect attorney's fees is the language contained in the trust itself.

Trust documents can contain provisions addressing expenses, administration, indemnification, or other matters that may become relevant when a dispute arises.

The language of one trust may be very different from another.


And even when a trust contains a provision addressing legal expenses, whether and how that provision applies can depend on the circumstances and the law of the applicable state.

That's why reviewing the actual trust document can be an important part of evaluating a trust dispute.


So, Who Pays Legal Fees in a Trust Dispute?


There isn't one answer that applies to every trust lawsuit.


As a general starting point, each party may be responsible for their own attorney's fees. But trust litigation can involve exceptions that change the financial picture.

Depending on the circumstances:


  • A trustee defending actions taken in their role as trustee may be able to have legal expenses paid from trust assets.


  • A beneficiary who brings a claim that benefits the trust as a whole may, in some circumstances, seek payment of attorney's fees from the trust.


  • A person who brings a frivolous or bad-faith claim may potentially be ordered to pay the other side's legal fees.


  • The language of the trust itself may affect how expenses are handled.


  • The law of the state where the dispute is taking place can significantly affect the outcome.


Ultimately, the answer may depend on the person's role, the specific claim being made, the conduct of the parties, the outcome of the litigation, the trust's language, and applicable state law.


Before Filing a Trust Lawsuit, Understand the Potential Costs


Trust litigation can involve significant financial and emotional costs.


If you're considering challenging a trust, it's worth understanding not only whether you may have a legal claim, but also what could happen financially if the dispute proceeds.


Likewise, if you're a trustee who has been sued, you may need to understand whether trust assets can be used to defend the claim and whether circumstances could later affect your right to reimbursement.


Because the rules surrounding attorney's fees can be complicated, the answer isn't something you should have to guess at.


An attorney familiar with trust and probate litigation can review the circumstances of your case, the trust documents, and the applicable state law and explain the potential issues that may affect your situation.


Talk to a Trust Litigation Attorney


If you're considering a trust challenge or you're a trustee facing a trust dispute, understanding the potential attorney's fees is an important part of understanding your options.

The attorneys at Woodbury & Ybarra handle trust, estate, and probate matters. They are experienced and specialize in these specific types of issues.


Visit Woodbury & Ybarra or call 801-203-0297 to schedule a consultation.



This article is provided for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Laws vary by state, and every legal matter is different.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page